Vintage Treasures: Echoes of Valor III, edited by Karl Edward Wagner

Vintage Treasures: Echoes of Valor III, edited by Karl Edward Wagner

Echoes of Valor III-smallAnd so we come to the end of our all-too-brief series on Karl Edward Wagner’s ambitious and highly regarded sword & sorcery anthologies. Echoes of Valor III was published in paperback by Tor Books in September 1991, just three years before poor Karl drank himself to death in 1994.

The three Echoes of Valor books are perplexing in some regards, especially for collectors. Wagner had taken a huge step towards literary respectability for Robert E. Howard in 1977, by compiling and editing the definitive three-volume hardcover collection of the unexpurgated Conan for Berkley: The People of the Black Circle, Red Nails, and The Hour of the Dragon. It’s clear that he intended Echoes of Valor to accomplish the same feat for a wider rage of his favorite writers, by assembling the defining collection of their best heroic fantasy in hardcover — and with non-fiction commentary that treated them to genuine scholarship.

It didn’t quite work out that way. The first volume of Echoes of Valor appeared only in paperback in 1987, and it had no non-fiction content at all. It was also burdened with a Ken Kelly cover that pretty obviously had originally been intended for Tor’s Conan line — I wouldn’t be surprised if most book shoppers in 1987 mistook it for just another Conan pastiche, and didn’t give it another glance.

With the second volume, Echoes of Valor II, Wagner finally got the book he’d aspired to. It appeared in hardcover in 1989 with an original cover by Rick Berry, and no less than eight non-fiction pieces (autobiographical sketches, forwards, and author appreciations) from four distinguished writers: C.L. Moore, Forrest J. Ackerman, Sam Moskowitz and Wagner himself.

Echoes of Valor II was one of the first books to treat sword & sorcery as serious fiction, and the hardcover format meant that Tor was able to sell it into libraries and schools across the country. It was a groundbreaking book for the genre. So it was a bit puzzling when Echoes of Valor III appeared three years later — exclusively in paperback, and with only one brief essay from Sam Moskowitz.

That’s not the only way Echoes of Valor III is different, however. Whereas the first volume featured only novellas, and the second chiefly short stories, for this one Wagner selected seven novelettes, plus one novella from Jack Willamson. He also gave over a third of the book — 125 pages — to a single author, Weird Tales writer Nictzin Dyalhis, who’s celebrated here with three novelettes and an appreciation from Moskowitz titled “Nictzin Dyalhis: Mysterious Master of Fantasy.”

Since all three volumes are so different, it’s easy to believe that Wagner had no strict format at all in mind for the Echoes of Valor books. We’ll probably never know for sure.

That’s all part of their mystery and charm, however. And no matter how you look at them, all three contain excellent fiction, and some very enjoyable and entertaining discussion of some of the greatest pulp fantasy of all time.

This volume contains “The Shadow of the Vulture” by Robert E. Howard, the story that introduced the world to the famous Red Sonya, a Hok the Mighty tale by Wagner’s close friend Manly Wade Wellman, a werewolf story by Jack Williamson, three stories by Nictzin Dyalhis, and two by Henry Kuttner.

Since I can never pass up an opportunity to showcase pulp art, here’s all the original magazines these stories appeared in:

The Magic Carpet Magazine January 1934-small Strange Stories April 1939-small Strange Stories August 1939-small

[Click on any of the images for bigger versions.]

Amazing Stories December 1939-small Strange Tales of Mystery and Terror January 1932-small Weird Tales February 1934-small

And here’s a look at Nictzin Dyalhis’ tales. Dyalhis was published almost exclusively in Weird Tales, but his fiction was reprinted in a number of magazines and paperbacks over the decades. The stories herein are “The Red Witch, from the April 1932 Weird Tales (cover by C. C. Senf), “The Sapphire Goddess” from Weird Tales, February 1934 (cover above right), reprinted as “The Sapphire Siren” in Avon Fantasy Reader #17, November 1951 (cover by Barton), and “The Sea-Witch,” from December 1937 Weird Tales (cover by the great Virgil Finlay.)

Weird Tales April 1932-small Avon Fantasy Reader 17-small Weird Tales December 1937-small

And here’s the complete table of contents for Echoes of Valor III:

“The Shadow of the Vulture” by Robert E. Howard (The Magic Carpet Magazine, January 1934)
“Cursed Be the City” by Henry Kuttner (Strange Stories, April 1939)
“The Citadel of Darkness” by Henry Kuttner (Strange Stories, August 1939)
“Hok Goes to Atlantis” by Manly Wade Wellman (Amazing Stories, December 1939)
“Wolves of Darkness” by Jack Williamson (Strange Tales of Mystery and Terror, January 1932)
Nictzin Dyalhis: Mysterious Master of Fantasy, by Sam Moskowitz
“The Red Witch” by Nictzin Dyalhis (Weird Tales, April 1932)
“The Sapphire Goddess ” by Nictzin Dyalhis (Weird Tales, February 1934)
“The Sea-Witch” by Nictzin Dyalhis (Weird Tales, December 1937)

We’ve previous covered the first two volumes:

Echoes of Valor (1987)
Echoes of Valor II (1989)

Echoes of Valor III was published by Tor Books in September 1991. It is 374 pages, priced at $3.99 in paperback. The cover was by Ricky Berry. It has never been reprinted, and there is no digital edition.

See all of our recent Vintage Treasures here.

Notify of

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Joe H.

Another great collection. And I love all of those covers!

Joe H.

Someone really needs to put together a Nictzin Dyalhis eBook collection.


Thanks for this series on Echoes of Valor, John. For me personally, they were some of the most important books I read in high school and college.

And I agree with Joe H. There needs to be a Nictzin Dyalhis ebook collection.

Sarah Avery

Now I begin to understand why KEW was such a big deal. I’d never really registered him as a presence in the genre until I became a regular reader here at BG.

On a completely frivolous note, I have to say that the name Nictzin Dyalhis looked so much like it had started as an anagram for something else, I had to go run it through an anagram generator. Although “Clannish Ditzy I” has its charms, “Chain Ditzy Nils” seems more like something that would happen in a Sword and Sorcery dungeon. “Cannily Hid Zits” described the indignities adolescence held for all of us. “Satiny Zilch Din” would be an excellent band name.”Zany Chitin Slid” could caption many pulp cover image. And that’s more than enough of that.


More information on Nictzin Dyalhis here –


I recently used all three of these for references for an article I was doing. Lots of great stuff in this series.


Good news, folks:

I was told by Jeff Betancourt himself that Wildside Press will be publishing a Nictzin Dyalhis Megapack eBook in the future. It’s yet to be determined whether it’ll be a part of their new Golden Age of Weird Fiction series or just a standard Megapack, but it’s definitely going to be published. I can’t wait!


BTW, I own Echoes of Valor III—it happens to be the only Echoes of Valor title I own. Hope to eventually add the others to my collection.

Joe H.

Excellent news! I’ll be picking up the Megapack as soon as it becomes available …

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x