Return Home

Art of the Genre: Top 10 Fantasy Artists of the Past 100 Years

Wednesday, August 17th, 2011 | Posted by Scott Taylor

Da Vinci didn't make the list because of the timeframe... but still... how about those eggs?

Da Vinci didn't make the list because of the timeframe... but still... how about those eggs?

So as it often happens here a BG L.A., John O’Neill issues a challenge and then we beat writers have to find a way to make it happen [Ok, so that only me and Ryan, but still]. John was looking over stories that got good hits from various sites around the internet and then phones me to say that I should do a piece on ‘Top 10s’ because people seem to really like top ten lists.

Ok, so after hanging up with him I yelled for Kandline to bring me the LA Times, which she was currently using to keep nail polish from dripping on her far too short skirt. After she made her way into my office I tried to convince her to help me determine what might be an interesting top ten. She suggested ‘Top 10 Disney stars who have a chance at winning an Oscar’, but Ryan Harvey shot that one down from his office next door as the sound of Miley Cyrus from the reception desk delivered wooden lines like a chorus of malevolent crows.

After some further consideration, these without my secretary’s help, I finally decided to go with the old standby of an art related article. That being said, I’m happy to bring you the Top 10 Fantasy Artists of the Past 100 Years.

Now you might be wondering how I came into possession of this list. Well, I went deep into my contacts and put together fifty names that consisted only of artists, art directors, convention organizers, and RPG publishers. Not a single voter on this panel didn’t have a vested interest in the topic at hand, and when all was said and done my list contained over fifty incredible names, but alas, I was only looking for 10, so that’s where we are. Oh, and if you’re wondering, no, I didn’t vote [no matter how much I would have loved to].

In all, I think the list not only contains the usual suspects, but also has some people you wouldn’t normally think of off the top of your head. It’s a truly wonderful list, and at the end of this piece I’ve decided to include all the artists who received at least one vote so that you can see the diversity that came out of the replies.

Number 10: Roy C. Krenkel, Boris Vallejo, and Manuel Sanjulian

Krenkel has the 'Eye of the Tiger'

Krenkel has the 'Eye of the Tiger'


Amazingly these artists came in at a dead heat to form a three-way tie for tenth place. Since I didn’t put in a factor for a tiebreaker, and I just didn’t feel right about cutting any one of them, I’ve decided to show you each! Yeah, it’s kind of like going into overtime.

Roy C. Krenkel: (1918-1983) was an American illustrator who is known for his close association with another American fantasy icon, Frank Frazetta. In the 1950s Krenkel graced the pages of magazines such as Weird Fantasy, Weird Science, and Weird Science-Fantasy and his work helped define pulp fanzines of that age. More a cartoonist than a cover artist, some of Krenkel’s most profound work was done in black and white, and the art of his lines never fails to amaze.

My Take: I like Krenkel, and as a huge fan of black and white work, I couldn’t be happier to see him included in this list. He did some outstanding work in the science fiction field as well, and I think that his women are true icons of a pin-up style inside the fantasy age.

With this Boris 'Jane', I'd live in the jungle without complaint!

With this Boris 'Jane', I'd live in the jungle without complaint!

Boris Vallejo: (1941-present) is a Peruvian-born American who immigrated to the United States in 1964. It was in the 1960s that his work was included in fantasy soft-covers in the swords and sorcery sub-genre. These oil paintings of muscle-bound barbarians and scantily clad females helped define his career, most of his work following in the school of Frank Frazetta-type art. Still, Vallejo himself has a great fondness for bringing power to the female form, and after his initial covers his artistic style began casting women as heroes instead of sidebars to male dominated imagery.

My Take: Boris did my favorite B movie poster of all time, that of Deathstalker II with Monique Gabrielle and John Terlesky. I absolutely love the style employed in his early work for the Gor novels, plus the simple fact that he is still putting out art and attending shows today says a great deal about his passion and dedication to the craft.

I'm feeling 'fanzine' all the way with this Sanjulian, and I like it!

I'm feeling 'fanzine' all the way with this Sanjulian, and I like it!

Manuel Sanjulian: (1941-Present) is a Spanish painter best known for his work with Warren Publishing, and especially his founding principles in the look of the horror seductress Vampirella. Although his work can be said to encompass all fantasy, he is more rightly known as a horror illustrator as he helped define fanzines of the 70s such as Eerie, Creepy, and as above Vampirella.

My Take: Well, Vampirella… need I say more? He brings a sense of movement and sex appeal to his work that isn’t captured by too many others, and I think is study of the female form is off the chart. As I’m too young to have delved deeply into horror fanzines, I’ll have to leave praise for his work there to a more practiced pro, Jeff Easley who says “The ability to unlock the surface of the painting ground and transform dabs of pigment into a new world at least as vivid as the one we live in is the capability most highly sought after by many artists. Sanjulian does this seemingly without effort and always without fail.” Well said!

Number 9: Greg and Tim Hildebrandt (Greg 1939-Present, Tim 1939-2006) are American born twin brothers who began their professional painting career together around 1960.

Faramir was always my favorite Tolkien character, and The Brothers Hildebrandt do him right.

Faramir was always my favorite Tolkien character, and The Brothers Hildebrandt do him right.

They’ve worked in countless genres, some of their most acclaimed work coming from the adaptation of Star Wars, The Lord of the Rings, The Sword of Shannara, Harry Potter, and even the collectable card game Magic: The Gathering. They are best known in popular culture as ‘The Brothers Hildebrandt’.

My Take: Well, I was always taken with their early work on Shannara, and although I could never actually get through one of those books, the cover art stands out in my mind as a beautiful representation of an epic fantasy world. Greg and Tim are certainly members of elite company, and their ability to share the craft of creation is in my opinion one of the more intriguing parts of their success.

Number 8: Jeffrey Catherine Jones (1944-2011) is an American artist who produced over 150 fantasy and science fiction covers during her career.

J Catherine Jones broke a mold and the world is better for it.

J Catherine Jones broke a mold and the world is better for it.

Frazetta once called Jones ‘the greatest living painter’, and her work helped frame paperbacks of the 70s with such classic texts as Fritz Leiber’s Fafhrd and The Gray Mouser. She also did comic work with the likes of Barry Windsor-Smith and Michael Kaluta.

My Take: This is a tough one because I’m just not that familiar with her art other than what I’ve studied as I put this article together. I will say this, there is form work here that makes me see a completely new possibility for art, and as I’m very familiar with the work of artist Rick Berry, I now have a much better understanding of what Rick does and where his kind of art has its roots.

Number 7: Larry Elmore (1948-Present) is an American fantasy artist best known for his work on the role-playing game Dungeons and Dragons through the 1980s. His oil paintings helped define the genre of role-playing games as he did covers for science fiction (Star Frontiers), gaming inspired novels (Dragonlance), fantasy magazines (Dragon), before moving on to video game design (Everquest) and collectable cards (Magic: The Gathering).

Larry Elmore can paint my D&D characters anytime, and twice on Sunday!

Larry Elmore can paint my D&D characters anytime, and twice on Sunday!

My Take: Well, Larry is Larry, and I’ve had the pleasure of working with him on a couple of occasions and each time it’s more fun. His work is still dominate in the industry he’s called home for more than 30 years, and you would be hard pressed to find a gamer of any age who can’t pick out the beauty of an Elmore painting. He has taken lovely to an entirely new level, and I have to say I was very pleased to see him place in this list.

Number 6: Arthur Rackham (1867-1937) is and English illustrator who created his own style of art using blocking and layering to create photographic-like images. His illustration work was used in plates for classic books including the Fairy Tales of the Brothers Grimm, Gulliver’s Travels by Jonathan Swift, Rip van Winkle by Washington Irving, and Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland by Lewis Carroll.

They don't make them like Arthur Rackham anymore, and children suffer for it...

They don't make them like Arthur Rackham anymore, and children suffer for it...

My Take: Well, it’s great to see that not every artist on this list was from the U.S., although I must say that fantasy in general is dominated by an American market [although oddly the two biggest fantasy writers of all time by an enormous margin are English, ala Tolkien and Rowling]. Again, I love black and white line art, and Rackham is a master of it, his style of using shadowed-stuff makes you think you’re looking at some old movie in a archaic viewer where only one of your eyes can see into.

Number 5: Brom (1965-Present) is an American artist known for his work in fantasy that mixes styles with a gothic format.

I like Brom, and you can too for three spiders, an eye of newt, and some bat wings...

I like Brom, and you can too for three spiders, an eye of newt, and some bat wings...


Brom’s initial delve into fantasy came with the gaming company TSR in the early 1990s, and his work on the Darksun Campaign Setting brought a dark apocalyptic future to fantasy for the first time. His work continued with contributions to darker gaming systems such as Deadlands and Vampire the Masquerade. He’s also created his own fiction novel using his gothic style with The Child Thief.

My Take: Brom is freaky, but I love him, and if it weren’t for him I’m going to go so far as to say that shiny vampires might not be burning up the bestseller lists. His gothic movement, trench coats, leather, and pale skin we keys to bringing dark fantasy and probably even urban fantasy into the light of day during the early 90s. There is no mistaking his talent, and the genre he chose to display his skills in just keep growing by the day… or should I say night?

Number 4: NC Wyeth (1882-1945) is a turn of the century American illustrator who was a pupil of American legend Howard Pyle.

Wyeth does his best King Arthur, and I'm sold.

Wyeth does his best King Arthur, and I'm sold.

His work competed with the rise of photography, and his paintings are sometimes felt to better represent reality than those of photographs. Although for the purpose of this article Wyeth is considered a ‘fantasy’ painter, much of his more famous work came in depicting scenes of the old west.

My Take: My grandfather loved Louis L’amour and basically anything that had to do with the old west. Wyeth gives us a window into this world, and I can see why many consider it to be a fantasy one because so many of the stories involved are dramatizations of expanded reality. His work frames a period that lives in legend among us all, and although we may have moved into a space age, Wyeth’s work keeps us grounded with incredible detail and color that bleeds into the page.

Number 3: Keith Parkinson (1958-2005) was an American painter who worked alongside Larry Elmore in the dawn of the oil period at the gaming giant TSR.

The Horde is coming!  And Parkinson shows us the face of our enemy...

The Horde is coming! And Parkinson shows us the face of our enemy...

His work transcended from Dungeons and Dragons to novel covers, and finally video games as he helped define early fantasy massive multi-player online role-playing games like Everquest and Vanguard. Keith also helped portray one of the largest selling fantasy novel series of the 1990s with his work on Terry Goodkind’s The Sword of Truth.

My Take: Ah Keith… if only I’d had the chance to know you… Keith was taken far too early from the artistic stage, and yet his work has obviously touched the great bulk of our voters. To me, Keith’s work sets the stage for my youth, and over the years I’ve come to love almost every image I’ve ever seen of his. It wouldn’t take much to have me detail a massive roll of all his works that mean something special to me, but it’s probably the same with the bulk of gamers from 1980 on.

Number 2: Michael Whelan (1950-Present) is a 16 time Hugo Award winning American painter who has helped define novel covers from 1980 forward.

Whelan takes beauty to a whole new level... in color, in form, and in imagination.

Whelan takes beauty to a whole new level... in color, in form, and in imagination.

His work is unchallenged in his field with work ranging from full fantasy, to horror, and science fiction. He has helped create the worlds of such famed authors as Anne McCaffrey (Dragonriders of Pern), Michael Moorcock (Elric of Melnibone), Stephen King (Gunslinger), and Ray Bradbury’s (The Martian Chronicles) to name but a few.

My Take: There are those people in the world of modern media that become connected to a subject more so than any other. In this fashion Don Lafontaine IS the voice of action movie trailers, Michael Buffer makes us all want to ‘get ready to rumble!’, and John Williams has somehow created the soundtrack to all our lives. Michael Whelan is this kind of person, the man who has single-handedly become ‘it’ for novel covers that define the genre.

Number 1: Frank Frazetta (1928-2010) is an American painter best known for his work defining Robert E. Howard’s Conan. His contributions on Conan transformed the fantasy genre in the 1960s, and he can be directly credited with creating what many consider to be the true stylistic essence of all swords and sorcery painting. His influence is so profound that it can be argued four members of this Top 10 actually maintain their position from using Frazetta’s techniques in their own work. His work has become so iconic that it transcended fantasy to become a part of pop culture. Frazetta... Conan... nuff' said...

My Take: Man, where do I start? Frazetta needs no introduction, and his work certainly doesn’t require my take, but I guess I’ll give it nonetheless. To me his has created a kind of central core that all other fantasy artists of this modern age pinwheel off of. If there were a dozen ‘Top 10’ lists about art, like form, composition, brushwork, color, etc, Frazetta would probably be at the top of each. That is what he means to the field, and if you ever have the chance to set down and see an original painting, take the time to just be quiet and enjoy it because if you think his book covers sing, you haven’t seen anything until the depth of an original stares back at you.

So there you have it, the Top 10 Fantasy Artists of the past 100 Years, but if you feel someone was left out, then have a look at the names that got votes but didn’t make it into the list above. I seriously doubt anyone was totally missed.

J. Allen St. John, Maxfield Parrish, Moebius, Alan Lee, Frank Kelly Freas, Jeff Easley, John Howe, Donato Giancola, Virgil Finlay, Howard Pyle, Tim Bradstreet, Brian Froud, Roger Dean, Jude Jude Palencar, Wayne Reynolds, Todd Lockwood, Dave Dorman, Phil Hale, Stephen Fabian, Hayao Miyazaki, Clyde Caldwell, Bernie Wrightson, Richard Corben, John Baur, Patrick Woodruffe, Eva Widermann, Steve Prescott, Erol Otus, Tyler Walpole, James Ryman, Ben Wooten, Ed Valigursky, Ed Emshwiller, Ian McCaig, James Gurney, Kevin Walker, Paul Bonner, Jack Kirby, Paul Lehr, Al Williamson, Enric Torres Prat, Wallace Wood, James Bama, Rodney Matthews, David Mattingly, Bob Peake, Charles Bragg, Yoshitaka Amano, Justin Sweet, Chris Achilleos, Juan Gimenez, Syd Mead, Maurice Sendak, Hal Foster, H.R. Giger, Philippe Druillet, Steve Youll, M.C. Esher, Edward Gorey, Arthur Wardle, Rien Poortvliet, James Gurney, Stan Winston, Mike Mignola, Joseph Clement Coll, Jim Fitzpatrick, Alicia Austin, Jeff Laubenstein, Tom Kidd, Frederick Lord Leighton, Alma-Tadema, J.W. Waterhouse, Salvador Dali, Caspar David Friedrich, Heinrich Kley, Gustave Dore, John R. Neill, Scott Gustafson


If you like what you read in Art of the Genre, you can listen to me talk about publishing and my current venture with great artists of the fantasy field or even come say hello on Facebook here. And my current RPG Art Blog can be found here. Also, for my hardcore fans and those that love small press books, I’ve launched my latest crowd-sourcing campaign that I’m determined to see become the most successful fantasy fiction Kickstarter of all time, so come help me and all my artist and writer friends create a franchise to remember!

24 Comments »

  1. I am surprised that Sanjulian is on the list and not Enrich, especially if Vampirella covers are being cited. Enrich defined the Vampirella brand as much as Gonzalez, especially the #31 cover that was never used.

    Sanjulian is a fine artist, make no mistake, just surprised at the relative ranking.

    Comment by DrCharlesForbin - August 17, 2011 4:00 am

  2. Oh yeah, and probably the greatest regret in my life is that, having moved to Joisey in late 90s, I did not make the pilgrimage to the Frazetta museum in Pennsylvania. Carpe diem!

    Comment by DrCharlesForbin - August 17, 2011 4:09 am

  3. I was really hoping Virgil Finlay would have cracked the top 10. I guess people don’t read enough pulp these days. :)

    Comment by Erik Mona - August 17, 2011 4:45 pm

  4. I read Howard Pyle’s Arthurian stories at just the right age for his illustrations to be The Definitive Arthurian Images for me. I’m using the first volume as a teaching text for the first time ever, rereading it for the first time in a couple of decades, and it’s uncanny how vividly my mind has preserved those illustrations, and some of the prose style. Utterly gorgeous, and well worth tracking down. B&N has an edition of the text out, since it’s public domain, but they got some other guy to illustrate it–what’s the point in that? This was the first occasion I’ve had to order a POD hardcover, and though the dust jacket printing is cheap, the interior illos are came out just as well as in the ancient copies my local library had in my childhood.

    Comment by Sarah Avery - August 17, 2011 9:29 pm

  5. No Rowena or Royo? Surely you jest! Otherwise a very good list, although I’d put Whelan first myself. Rowena did a magnificent job on the two covers she did for me and I really like the ones she did for Piers Anthony too.

    Comment by Theo - August 18, 2011 1:54 pm

  6. Dr Forbin: Thanks for the comments. Again, I’ll say I had no hand in making this list other than to ask the question to 50 professionals :)

    As for the Frazetta museum, I lived less than three hours away from it for 10 years and didn’t get there… a true shame on my part…

    Comment by Scott Taylor - August 18, 2011 7:06 pm

  7. Erik: You’re not the only one! I think I’ve had a dozen emails asking after Finlay :) Remember, however, you were a voter, so you got your say ;)

    Comment by Scott Taylor - August 18, 2011 7:07 pm

  8. Sarah: I always love it when you comment, and I wish you’d stop in more often. I’ll have to look that book up, but if the art’s not there, it will be hard to buy it…

    Comment by Scott Taylor - August 18, 2011 7:08 pm

  9. Theo: Wow, you went an entire podcast with John O’Neill and didn’t once mention my existence, but I finally have a comment from you. I guess I’m moving up in the world ;) Oh, and if I made a list [which I did but won't share it] Royo would have/was on it.

    Comment by Scott Taylor - August 18, 2011 7:09 pm

  10. Disappointed not to see Richard Powers, a, if not THE, master of abstract fantasy art! (Or did my old eyes miss it?)

    Comment by bnrtn - August 19, 2011 2:23 am

  11. [...] a book cover or classic work of art can inspire you to think of something for your game… Well Scott Taylor at Black Gate has posted a list of the top 10 fantasy artists from the last 100 years, with samples. A few of the classic artists whose names you may have seen before… Boris [...]

    Pingback by RPG News from Around the Net: 19-AUG-2011 | Game Knight Reviews - August 19, 2011 7:05 am

  12. BNRTN: Nope, I don’t think a soul picked Richard Powers… although I’d say he’s not the only one ‘missed’. Daniel Horne is also another incredible artist who didn’t make the cut, as well as Angus McBride.

    Comment by Scott Taylor - August 19, 2011 7:20 am

  13. Did I miss Bob Eggleton’s name in the list of top vote getters? If not, umm, really? Full disclosure, Bob is a good friend, but I don’t think I’m being excessively biased in my belief that he should be mentioned here on the strength of his 11 art-related Hugos, plus nominations for Best Pro Artist virtually every year for the past 2 decades, and mostly for an awe-inspiring body of work, especially when it comes to dragons, Lovecraft, space paintings and kaiju monsters.

    Comment by KStoddardHayes - August 19, 2011 12:54 pm

  14. Well, I don’t begrudge the artists listed, although your postscript and the comments above point out the hazards involved in such lists. One can only put 10 in a 10 list. Kudos for your efforts to augment it! I’ve seen and appreciated the art of many of those listed or mentioned and will look up some I didn’t know of. Thanks!

    Comment by bnrtn - August 19, 2011 7:19 pm

  15. Scott: It’s always a pleasure to join the conversation here.

    Comment by Sarah Avery - August 20, 2011 12:26 am

  16. KSH: Indeed, no Eggleton to be found. I’m also intrigued that no Darrell K. Sweet, who would have also made my list and yet not a single mention in 50 pollers. It’s strange how minds work ;)

    Comment by Scott Taylor - August 21, 2011 10:22 am

  17. [...] Art of the Genre: Top 10 Fantasy Artists of the Past 100 Years [...]

    Pingback by Geek Media Round-Up: August 22, 2011 – Grasping for the Wind - August 22, 2011 9:02 am

  18. I think you couldn’t expect such controversy with the top 10 and the complementary list when you post this article but apart Rowena Merrill and Luis Royo (just like theo I noticed their absence) where is Ken Kelly? and comic magazines artists like Earl Norem or Joe Jusko?

    by the way couldn’t be interesting a list of fantasy artists before the XX century? those who were inspired by literaries or mythological themes like William Blake (I should read the article by Mathew David Surridge on him) Gustave Dore, Jean Pierre David or the history inspired Lawrence Alma Tadema?

    Comment by francisco72 - August 23, 2011 6:02 pm

  19. This is really a Top 12 list with a 3-way tie for 10th (literalist with OCD comment). Another talented artist with a distinct voice who’s conspicuous by his absence is John Picacio. I’m not personally familiar with Dali’s fantasy work. If he’s included for the fantastic quality of his surrealist work, what about other surrealists? (Magritte is my favorite) On the other hand, I agree with the exclusion of Rowena. She does great stuff, but it’s too similar to Vallejo’s.

    Comment by hooded.swan - August 24, 2011 6:34 am

  20. I missed two names there which I bring up more as a sort of reminder of their work than their artistic status: Hans Bok who was a close friend of A. Merrit and illustrated some of his works; also Clark Ashton Smith, who besides writing some wonderfully weird mystic-horror also dabbled in some sculpture and drwing or paintings or both (recollection dims).

    Comment by eirik - December 16, 2011 2:39 am

  21. [...] my all-time favorite artists.  When Scott Taylor asked me to provide my list of nominees for his Top 10 Fantasy Artists of the Past 100 Years post, I had Wood right near the [...]

    Pingback by Black Gate » Blog Archive » New Treasures: Wally Wood: Strange Worlds of Science Fiction - January 23, 2012 3:20 pm

  22. Lists like this can be flamewar bait. I’m not going on a foaming rant, ok?

    I argue politely for:

    1. Sidney Sime – illustrated a lot of Dunsany’s works and others during the essential genesis era of modern Fantasy fiction.

    2. Virgil Finlay – the master of perfect B&W ink artwork, he inspired a ton of later artworks.

    3. Kelley Freas – again, countless images that later inspired future artists. More or less he was a part of the 50s/60s genre defining stuff, the style later used by cool guys like Riccardi for Samurai Jack/Regulators, etc. He was a strong sub-artist of Finlay, but quite accomplished on his own.

    4. Wally Wood, who did countless comic book art, again a big influence on later artists from Kirby to Kaluta.

    These artists both had unique talent and styles that helped both define the genre and inspire later ones. I like Boris, but he shouldn’t be on such a narrow list since he’s in the shadow of Frazetta, who should still be #1 he’s just too perfect past and future!

    Comment by GreenGestalt - January 26, 2012 2:40 am

  23. Green: Again, not my list, and I’d agree people I thought should be on there weren’t even mentioned… :(

    Comment by Scott Taylor - January 26, 2012 11:09 am

  24. [...] Moebius was ever my enigma, and when I did my list of the Top 10 Fantasy Artists of the Past 100 Years back in 2011, Moebius might not have made the final list but he did receive a healthy number of [...]

    Pingback by Black Gate » Blog Archive » Art of the Genre: Jean Giraud ‘Moebius’ 1938-2012 - March 14, 2012 12:04 am


Comments RSS  |  TrackBack URI

 

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Black Gate Home
This site © 2014 by New Epoch Press. All rights reserved.