The three book Echoes of Valor anthology series from TOR was edited by Karl Edward Wagner, who wrote excellent Sword & Sorcery tales himself, and could recognize good ones when he saw them. These were not anthologies of new stories, but reprints. Each contained a Robert E. Howard tale. Here are some capsule reviews.

Echoes of Valor (1987, Cover Ken Kelly)

Contains one story each by Robert E. Howard, Fritz Leiber, and Henry Kuttner. Howard’s story is “The Black Stranger.” It’s a Conan tale but wasn’t published in REH’s lifetime. He rewrote it as a pirate tale featuring Black Vulmea called “Swords of the Red Brotherhood.” It still didn’t sell. Long after Howard’s death, L. Sprague de Camp rewrote it as “The Treasure of Tranicos” and it was published. It didn’t really need the rewrite in my opinion, so who knows why it wasn’t published initially.

Leiber’s story is “Adept’s Gambit,” starring his two usual rogues; Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser. It’s one of the best tales in the series. Kuttner’s story is “Wet Magic,” which I also enjoyed. It has Nazis, swords, and sorceresses. What more could you ask for?

Echoes of Valor II (1991, Cover Sam Rakeland, aka Rick Berry)

Contains stories by Howard, C. L. Moore, Manly Wade Wellman, and a collaboration by Leigh Brackett and a young Ray Bradbury. REH’s stories are “The Frost-King’s Daughter” and “The Frost-Giant’s Daughter,” which are variants of the same story featuring Amra (King’s) and Conan (Giant’s).

The four stories by Moore, all involving Northwest Smith, were excellent. The Brackett/ Bradbury story was even better. The complete Wellman story was “Hok Visits the Land of Legends.” I found it pretty weak. There was also a Hok Fragment that was much better. If you were being introduced to Wellman, this might not have been the way to do it.

Echoes of Valor III (1991, Cover Sam Rakeland)

Stories by Howard, Kuttner, Wellman, Jack Williamson, and Nictzin Dyalhis. Howard’s story is the only authentic Red Sonya story, “The Shadow of the Vulture,” which has always been a favorite of mine. Kuttner’s stories are the only two he did about a character named Prince Raynor, who lived during a time when the Gobi Desert was the seat of a civilization. Both are good. “Hok Goes to Atlantis,” by Wellman, was better than the Hok story in Echoes of Valor II, but not outstanding.

“Wolves of Darkness” by Jack Williamson was quite good, though it could have been shortened. Dyalhis was represented by three short tales, “The Red Witch,” “The Sapphire Goddess,” and “The Sea-Witch,” each of which was excellent. These stories definitely made me look for more by this author. There’s also a nice introduction on Dyalhis by Sam Moskowitz. Dyalhis was a mysterious character, and one worth digging into I think. I’ll post more about him eventually.

Folks here at Black Gate have dug into Echoes of Valor over the years; those articles are here:

Echoes of Valor
Echoes of Valor II
Echoes of Valor III

---

Charles Gramlich administers The Swords & Planet League group on Facebook, where this post first appeared. His last article for us was an obituary for Heroic Historicals: Robert E. Howard, Harold Lamb, Poul Anderson and James Clavell. See all of his recent posts for Black Gate here.