Return Home

New Treasures: Songs of the Dying Earth

Friday, December 3rd, 2010 | Posted by John ONeill

sotdyWe get a lot of review copies here at the rooftop headquarters of Black Gate magazine, and it’s always a treat when the mail truck arrives. Getting free books never gets old, and we usually drop everything to tear open packages and pass around the most intriguing titles.

What is unusual is for a single book to bring all toil to a complete standstill for half an hour  (except for the tireless Howard Andrew Jones, who’s been missing in the restricted section of our pulp library for the last 48 hours). That’s exactly what happened when Songs of the Dying Earth (SotDE), edited by George R.R. Martin and Gardner Dozois, arrived today.

SotDE is a tribute collection; its subtitle is Stories in Honor of Jack Vance, and it contains nearly 700 pages of original fiction set in Vance’s Dying Earth — one of the great settings in all of fantasy, and home to Turjan the wizard, Rhialto the Marvellous, Cugel the Clever, and other fabulous characters. The Dying Earth is a far-future Terra, where the sun is on the verge of extinction, magic is potent and terrible, monsters roam the land, and the ruins of countless civilizations rest uneasily beneath layers of thin dust and vegetation.

dying-earth2The table of contents is one of the most impressive I’ve ever seen — it read like a Who’s Who of the most influential fantasy authors of the decade, including Robert Silverberg, George R.R. Martin, Walter Jon Williams, Jeff VanderMeer, Tad Williams, Glen Cook, Tanith Lee, Howard Waldrop, Elizabeth Hand, Lucius Shepard, Neil Gaiman, Phyllis Eisenstein, Liz Williams, Matthew Hughes, Terry Dowling, Mike Resnick, Paula Volsky, Kage Baker, John C. Wright, and others. It also includes a big new novella from Dan Simmons, an appreciation by Dean Koontz, and a preface by Jack Vance himself.

SotDE was first published in a limited edition by Subterranean Press last July; since then the book — and many of the stories — have received considerable attention. Jeff VanderMeer’s H.P. Lovecraft-inspired tale “The Final Quest of the Wizard Sarnod” has been turned into a novel, and SotDE was nominated for Best Anthology in the 2010 Locus Awards. Neil Gaiman’s story “An Invocation of Incuriosity” took home the Best Short Story prize at the same Awards.

Songs of the Dying Earth: Stories in Honor of Jack Vance goes on sale Dec. 7th. It is published by Tor books, in hardcover for $27.99, and gets our highest recommendation.


  1. Yes! I’ve been waiting for the (affordably priced) softcover…

    Comment by John R. Fultz - December 3, 2010 2:26 am

  2. […] Black Gate Tags: Dying, Earth, Songs, Treasures […]

    Pingback by » Blog Archive » New Treasures: Songs of the Dying Earth - December 3, 2010 7:36 am

  3. This book sounds grand save for the absence of Michael Shea. Shea’s first novel, A Quest for Simbilis (Daw,1974), was a full-on Dying Earth pastiche authorized by Vance himself. As heretical as it may sound, I enjoyed Shea’s novel, especially its wonder-laden finale, as much as any Vance I’ve read.

    Comment by John Hocking - December 3, 2010 8:21 am

  4. I have the Subterranean Press edition, and let me tell you, this anthology is awesome. I barreled through half of it until I had to stop myself, taking my time enjoying the stories. I’ve never read Michael Shea’s Cugel sequel, but I have read his story “Hew The Tintmaster” in Swords & Dark Magic. I found it to be pretty entertaining but nowhere near the caliber of the stories found in this one. Quite possibly my favorite anthology of all time. 😀

    Comment by TheMoose65 - December 3, 2010 9:41 am

  5. John RF,

    This actually isn’t a softcover (although that’s doubtless coming at some point). It’s a very thick hardcover, still reasonably priced at $27.99. Amazon has it for just $16.66 if you pre-order it.

    Comment by John ONeill - December 3, 2010 11:14 am

  6. John Hocking,

    I agree — I scratched my head at the omission of Shea myself. He was the first to write authorized work in Vance’s world, and arguably he showed the way for everyone else.

    On the other hand, as TheMoose65 points out, Shea just published a new Cugel story in SWORDS & DARK MAGIC, so perhaps he chose that anthology over SotDE to reach a new audience?

    At least SotDE includes Matthew Hughes, who’s been writing stories and novels (the Archonate stories) set just before the era of the Dying Earth, “the penultimate age of Old Earth.” I’ve really been enjoying those.

    The other author I miss is Gene Wolfe, whose Book of the New Sun was clearly influenced by Vance. I would have loved to see what he would have done in Vance’s playground.

    Comment by John ONeill - December 3, 2010 11:23 am

  7. TheMoose65,

    Thanks for the great review! Sounds like the anthology lives us to expectations. :)

    Comment by John ONeill - December 3, 2010 11:24 am

  8. I loved this anthology. Highly recommended to those who liked the original. Especially because many of the stories live up to the spirit of the Dying Earth so beautifully.

    Comment by peadarog - December 3, 2010 11:37 am

  9. This is a wonderful anthology. Probebly the best I’ve read in years. I too am suprised that michael Shea wasn’t included.
    The “Quest for Simbilis” is a very enjoyable book. It’s very much a “vancian” style and story. I didn’t get into Jack Vance until 2 years ago. I has read some of his stuff back in the middle 70s and as a Jr. Highscholler couldn’t realy get into his stories. Now at 49 I can’t get enough and have been making up for lost time by reading one book after the other. I lucked out by finding an on-line shop over here (I’m an ex-pat Buckeye living in Germany.) and bought over 20 books of his at only €1 a pop. I stil haven’t figured out why I didn’t like him as a kid. These are to the most part the best stories I’ve read in years. I’m so hapy that I have quite a few to read still.
    take care.

    Comment by doug - December 4, 2010 7:02 am

  10. […] was a Vance pastiche (what we’d call fan fiction today). The 2010 Jack Vance tribute volume Songs of the Dying Earth included contributions from George R.R. Martin, Dan Simmons, Robert Silverberg, Tad Williams, Glen […]

    Pingback by Black Gate » Blog Archive » Jack Vance, August 28, 1916 — May 26, 2013 - May 30, 2013 2:10 pm

  11. […] de Vance (lo que hoy se conoce como Fan Fiction). El volumen del 2010 en tributo a Jack Vance, «Songs of the Dying Earth», contó con las contribuciones de  George R.R. Martin, Dan Simmons, Robert Silverberg, Tad […]

    Pingback by INTROVISION: Un Adiós Desde una Tierra Agonizante | Zothique The Last Continent - June 3, 2013 10:52 am

  12. […] Love and Death (2010), urban fantasy-focused Down These Strange Streets (2011), Jack Vance tribute Songs of the Dying Earth (2010), the 800-page Dangerous Women (2013), and (my personal favorite) Old Mars. But now […]

    Pingback by Black Gate » Blog Archive » Future Treasures: Rogues edited by George R.R. Martin and Gardner Dozois - May 5, 2014 1:50 pm

  13. […] anthologies include the massive heroic fantasy volume Warriors (2010), the Jack Vance tribute Songs of the Dying Earth (2010), and last year’s Rogues (2014). See Letson’s complete review […]

    Pingback by Black Gate » Blog Archive » New Treasures: Old Venus, edited by George R.R. Martin and Gardner Dozois - March 12, 2015 10:56 pm

Comments RSS  |  TrackBack URI


Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Black Gate Home
This site © 2020 by New Epoch Press. All rights reserved.