Return Home

Galaxy Science Fiction, June 1953: A Retro-Review

Friday, July 29th, 2016 | Posted by Matthew Wuertz

Galaxy June 1953-smallThe June, 1953 issue of Galaxy didn’t include any serial fiction. If you’re looking for a good issue to read just to get a flavor of Galaxy without any commitment, I’d suggest this one.

“Tangle Hold” by F. L. Wallace — Jadiver’s autobath malfunctions, burning him with steam to the point that he nearly dies. A doctor replaces his skin with a synthetic version, and he’s eventually released from care to continue with his life.

Jadiver used to be a robot designer on Earth, but Earth was too crowded. He moved to Venus two years ago, but his skills aren’t as useful to society — except criminal society. He can design body costumes to change people’s appearances to help them go wherever they want without restriction.

When Jadiver becomes aware that his entire body has been redesigned as a type of surveillance unit for the police, he tries to understand its limitations and how he might be able to escape from the planet.

Wallace’s story has great pacing. There are enough questions to keep readers interested and engaged, and the answers come at the right moments, without being obvious.

“The Water Eater” by Win Marks — The narrator fixes his oil stove and dumps the excess oil into a roaster. To clean the roaster, he combines multiple cleaners together with hot water.

After dinner, he finds that the combination of oil and cleaners has become gelatinous. And it expands when water is added. Not only does it expand, but it tries to reach out toward the source of water to consume more.

The narration of the story works really well. He had a strong voice.

Galaxy June 1953 contents-small

“Warm” by Robert Sheckley — While Anders gets ready for his date with Judy, he hears a voice pleading for help. The speaker doesn’t know where he is but wants help in getting out. Anders isn’t certain how to find a disembodied person, but the voice guides him in seeing the world differently, noting that Anders is getting warm with each discovery.

I didn’t feel attached to the main character of the story. And I couldn’t quite understand the conclusion. Was Sheckley trying to say something about reality or just telling a tale?

Galaxy June 1953 Warm by Robert Sheckley

“First Lady” by J. T. M’Intosh — Joe and Ellen escort a young woman named Shirley to the planet Lotrin. Shirley will be the planet’s First Lady – a symbol that the planet’s society has transitioned from early explorers to a true settlement. When the First Lady and her appointed husband have their first child, scientists and doctors examine the infant and decide if the world should be settled or not. If not, then no other women are sent to the planet, and the people will live out the remainder of their days in isolation, their planet marked as a plague spot.

Ellen’s character stands out far above the other two, which makes the story a bit disappointing since M’Intosh brings a strong characterization to only one of the main characters. The plot itself is less interesting than seeing the characters interact during the journey, but I was fine with that since I would gladly trade plot for characters. (By that, I mean if I was given the choice between a detailed plot or detailed characters, I’d choose the characters.)

Galaxy June 1953 Emsh art

“We Don’t Want Any Trouble” by James H. Schmitz — A disparate group of scientists and military personnel interrogate a captured alien. Despite various threats, the alien refuses to divulge its purposes. The group soon learns that any threats they conceive are impossible to implement, including death.

The descriptions around the alien from the main character’s perspective are interesting in that they’re based on fear. This adds a nice contrast from those who want to intimidate the alien. But the story itself isn’t that impressive.

Galaxy June 1953 interior art 2

“if you were the only-” by Richard Wilson — A company builds two robots who appear to be human. When a war escalates, the project loses importance, and the robots are deactivated and placed in the locked storage area of the basement. One of the technicians is attracted to the robot that appears to be a woman, so he activates it. But the robot feels threatened and revives the other robot, which kills the man. Alone and locked in the storage area, the robots try to adjust to their new lives, learning about themselves through interactions with each other.

Wilson achieves a bit of sentimentality while maintaining the fact that this isn’t a human couple — that they are robots who are always fully aware they’re robots.

Galaxy June 1953 Colony Philip K Dick-small

“Colony” by Philip K. Dick — A team studies a new planet, trying to find any life-forms harmful to mankind. When they seem to have completed their research, the assault begins. One man is attacked by a microscope and then a towel. Except they aren’t the original microscope or towel; organisms mimic the inanimate objects. There is no way to tell the mimicry apart from the authentic until it’s too late, so the only course is to abandon the planet, provided they can do so without any objects.

This seems more like horror than science fiction, especially in reading one scene where a man is returning to his vehicle — only it’s not his vehicle. And the ending just made me think, “Oh no.” Horror fans might be amused by this one; I tend to avoid horror stories, but I admit this is a good one.


Matthew Wuertz’s last retro review for us was the May 1953 issue of Galaxy.

4 Comments »

  1. The retro-reviews of science fiction magazines are probably may favorite features at Black Gate. The magazines were the beating heart of sf in their day.

    Comment by Major Wootton - July 30, 2016 11:04 am

  2. Major Wootton,

    Thanks! I love reading Galaxy and sharing my thoughts on what I’ve read. :-)

    Comment by Matthew Wuertz - July 30, 2016 12:52 pm

  3. Overall I think this was a good issue. Nothing too outstanding but no real clunkers either.

    Mr. Gold should stay away from social commentary. I think he wants to sound progressive and look like a visionary, but his editorials just don’t impress me.

    “Tangle Hold” has some great technological ideas, but goes on a little longer than it needs to. The ending didn’t really resolve much, it just provided Jadiver with a means of escape. Unresolved endings are a theme this month.

    I did enjoy “The Water Eater.” The simple premise gives a nice problem and an absolutely evil ending, just when it seems everything was ok. I usually don’t care for heavy narrator voices, but this one was readable enough that it worked for me.

    Willy Ley’s science articles are second only to Asimov’s in F&SF. Mr. Ley does a nice job explaining the mysteries around prime numbers, but fails spectacularly when answering a question about the apparent size of the moon.

    I really felt for poor Anders in “Warm.” It is hard enough to talk to girls without voices in your head making you even more flustered and confused. Been there. I was fascinated as I read how his world slowly dissolved into emotionless components. I am not sure I bought into the full-circle ending, but the story is nevertheless a winner.

    If we could talk to girls we would spend a lot less time in SciFi blogs.

    J.T. M’intosh always delivers. “First Lady” kept me guessing with its many twists. The ending was almost predictable as the least likely outcome. This could be thought of as a human nature study. The fiendish plot and teamwork to manipulate this young lady to perform her duty, well, it might actually work on some people. Most people?

    “Trouble” is a very short story that probably could have been shorter. I did not find the story or the ending very interesting or creative.

    “If You Were The Only…” was close to being my pick for the winner this month. The ideas are nothing new…humanoid robots who can fit in without being discovered. I enjoyed the developmental section where they had to make a life for themselves when they discover they are trapped. The bits of fifties gender stereotypes were amusing, as always. The casual manner in which the fellow who discovers them is killed is almost shocking. However, the ending, once again this month, leaves too much unresolved. Maybe Mr. Wilson wanted a Romeo and Juliet type of effect, but the story doesn’t really set up that way. There is still the possibility of another awakening, but I really think the author was going for a tragedy.

    Please folks, finish your stories. I don’t want to have to learn how to talk to girls.

    Predictably, PKD is the winner this month with “Colony.” Everything is coming along nicely in the new settlement until some bizarre and frightening things begin to occur. Everything that was deficient in this month’s near-misses was present in this story. The reader is taken from pastoral solitude to unpredictable terror around every corner. Once we find out just how bad the problem is, an escape is planned, only this time it is not the author escaping from writing an end to his story. Even though you can see it coming, the tragic ending is deliciously dark.

    I am enjoying this journey every month. Thank you!

    Comment by GusG - July 30, 2016 11:27 pm

  4. Gus,

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts on the issue. “Colony” was good. I couldn’t pick an overall favorite in this issue. There were some good stories, but nothing really popped out as one I’d say I enjoyed more than the others.

    Comment by Matthew Wuertz - July 31, 2016 4:35 pm


Comments RSS  |  TrackBack URI

 

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Black Gate Home
This site © 2018 by New Epoch Press. All rights reserved.