The Public Life of Sherlock Holmes: Lord of Misrule

The Public Life of Sherlock Holmes: Lord of Misrule

LeeQuestion – What do Dracula, Frankenstein, the Mummy, James Bond, Fu Manchu, Star Wars, The Lord of the Rings, John Belushi and Sherlock Holmes all have in common?

Answer – Lee. Christopher Lee (one of his autobiographies was titled Lord of Misrule)

In May, talented British actor Christopher Lee turns 92 years old. Thanks to his performance as Saruman in the Lord of the Rings trilogy, he is as popular today as he ever has been. And proving he knows how to get in on a winning franchise, he was Count Dooku in the second Star Wars trilogy. Which chronologically was the… oh, never mind.

But Lee first made his name in the horror flicks produced by Hammer Films in Great Britain in the late fifties and sixties. Lee played the monster (Dracula, Frankenstein, the Mummy), while friend Peter Cushing was the protagonist.

Cushing and Lee from Hammer’s Hound. They both made solid Holmes’

The two even paired up in 1959 for Hammer’s garish Hound of the Baskervilles: Cushing was Sherlock Holmes while Lee played Sir Henry Baskerville in what is commonly cited as the best Hound film of them all.

A few years later, Lee himself would don the Inverness cape in the disappointing Sherlock Holmes & The Deadly Necklace. A multinational effort filmed in Germany, it suffered from too many cooks (two directors?) and an incoherent script revision.

But worst of all, in the end every bit of dialogue by Lee and Walters was dubbed by other actors from England … into English!  Plans for a sequel were immediately abandoned, though that fledgling effort eventually became A Study in Terror, in which John Neville’s Holmes took on Jack the Ripper.

If you recognize Moriarty’s driver, he went on to play General Burkhalter in Hogan’s Heroes (I’m pretty sure his voice was dubbed as well!).

Holmes_LeeNeclaceLee turned in a solid performance and he said, “My portrayal of Holmes is, I think, one of the best things I’ve ever done because I tried to play him really as he was written – as a very intolerant, argumentative, difficult man – and I looked extraordinarily like him with the make-up on…”

Not long afterwards, Lee would portray Sax Rohmer’s Fu Manchu in five films helmed by Harry Alan Towers. And he popped up as Sherlock’s brother Mycroft in Billy Wilder’s The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes. All of which leads us to Sherlock Holmes: The Golden Years.

In late 1990, Towers and Lee reunited to film two Holmes movies for television. From Towers:

It’s going to be eight one-hour adventures set in the days when Holmes is a worldwide celebrity and can’t go anywhere without meeting equally famous people who welcome him as a friend. Against wonderfully exotic backgrounds he does the good old Sherlock Holmes stuff and solves mysteries.

And there you go. Former Avenger Patrick MacNee was tapped as Watson (he had been a forgettable one in Roger Moore’s Sherlock Holmes in New York). Since both men were nearing seventy, we were getting a senior Holmes and Watson.

Holmes_LeeLeadingLadyThe idea of eight one-hour episodes was quickly scrapped and two three-hour movies were written. Bob Shayne (writer of 1987’s forgettable The Return of Sherlock Holmes) penned both scripts. They were far too long and meandered all over the place. Tightly plotted, ninety-minute episodes would have been much stronger.

The first film, Sherlock Holmes & The Leading Lady, featured the still vivacious Morgan Fairchild as Irene Adler. Almost thirty-years younger than Lee and looking even more so, the romantic angle between the two was irreparably flat.

Filmed in Vienna and Budapest, the script includes Sigmund Freud, Emperor Franz Joseph, Eliot Ness, and anarchists: the only thing missing in the credits is the kitchen sink. It’s watchable, but probably only once.

Holmes_LeeMacneeIncident at Victoria Falls (filmed second but shown first) was shot in brutal heat in ninety days in Zimbabwe, with only a two-day break after finishing The Leading Lady. Lee recounted a railroad car scene where it was about one hundred thirty degrees inside.

Even though Sherlockian H.R. Keating helped out on both films, Bob Shayne’s script was again flawed. The premise of this one isn’t bad: Holmes is sent to Africa by King Edward VII to safeguard The Star of Africa (a diamond). Much shenanigans and skullduggery ensue.

Theodore Roosevelt (amusingly played by Claude Aiken), Lillie Langtry (Jenny Seagrove: Mary Morstan opposite Jeremy Brett’s Holmes), Raffles, Marconi, and Edward VII make up the guest list this time around.

Once again, it’s just too long and wanders all over the place. It’s unfortunate, as the pieces were there for a solid Holmes movie. Both films were delayed, went straight to video and then shown on US television, considerably edited down (Seagrove is completely cut out of Incident).

Cushing and Stock from the BBC TV series

Lee is a pretty good elderly Holmes, though MacNee, better than in New York, doesn’t add much. He was actually third choice, but Nigel Stock (Watson opposite Peter Cushing and Douglas Wilmer) and Gordon Jackson (British TV veteran) were dead. To give MacNee credit, he wasn’t a shadow of Nigel Bruce.

The idea for this series was better than the execution and, because of the poor scripts, the films are rather dull. This is a shame, as Christopher Lee was given the deerstalker three times without the structural support to make a memorable Holmes film.

Holmes_LeeDVDA classic Dracula, Frankenstein, mummy, and wizard, Christopher Lee absolutely had the makings of a great Sherlock Holmes. A DVD package, including both movies, is readily available for $5.00. Lee’s performance is certainly worth that small price.

If you want a Holmes kick, watch Harry Allen Towers’s The Brides of Fu Manchu. Lee plays the diabolical doctor of evil, former Holmes Douglas Wilmer is Nayland Smith and Howard Marion Crawford, who played Watson 39 times opposite the under-appreciated Ronald Howard, is Dr. Petrie.

The relatively young Ian McKellen has been tapped to play an octogenarian Holmes in A Slight Trick of the Mind. Could not Saruman be enticed to make a guest appearance in Gandalf’s Holmes film?

And in case you were wondering, Lee played the German naval captain in John Belushi’s silly but enjoyable 1941.

I could have been a great Holmes. (sigh) And what’s with this plaid?
Notify of

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
James McGlothlin

I know the post is mainly about Lee’s Sherlock roles, but since you threw out the 1941 reference, don’t forget Lee’s creepy role in The Wicker Man!

[…] Click here to read it all at Black Gate: […]

Joe H.

Another thing I’ll do once I build my time machine is get Hammer-era Christopher Lee to star in a Solomon Kane film adaptation.

Joe H.

Yes, Cushing could also have done a fine job.


You are absolutely right about Christopher Lee. I have wanted to see him as Holmes since he did that “Hound of the Baskervilles” in which he wasn’t Holmes. It was so obvious when he and Cushing were in a scene together that it was Lee who looked like Holmes (I had been hearing Cushing was okay in the other Holmes stories he did so I just got in the three discs of that hoping not to be distracted by Lee in the others).

I have liked “A Study in Terror” (seen off TV) as the Holmes was reasonably good and so was the Watson (and that doesn’t always happen) but now that you tell me that Christopher Lee could have been that Holmes, I may never be able to enjoy it again. He really never did get a good chance to play Holmes in a reasonably good movie. A great loss to the Holmes films available.

[…] The Public Life of Sherlock Holmes: Lord of Misrule […]

[…] early nineties. The plots are plodding, but Lee plays a solid Holmes. You, dear reader, of course, already read my column on Lee’s turns as Holmes, […]

[…] Lord of Misrule – Christopher Lee as the great detective […]

[…] Mazarin Stone, The Last Vampyre1991-1992 Christopher Lee – The Golden Years2010-2017 Benedict Cumberbatch – Sherlock (Post One, Post Two, Post […]

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x