The Disney/Pixar partnership has always been willing to take some risks. Let’s face it, these are the people who turned a lost fish, talking cars, and Ed Asner in a floating house into deeply rich character-driven stories about the human condition. It’s really a wonder if there’s anything they can’t do well!
But one thing that they have avoided, until now, is even trying to dip their toes into the genre that Disney has mastered: the fairy tale.
From my perspective, with Brave they’ve blown pretty much every Disney fairy-tale-themed film out of the water. I won’t get much into the plotline, because Pixar’s done a really good job of not spoiling it too much. (I had a guess about what was going to happen, based largely on the Subway restaurant promotional campaign materials, and that guess was pretty much on the mark.)
But, even with no idea what happens in the film, there are a lot of things that the film is about which I can discuss…
Lessons That Ring With Truth
Over at my personal blog, I’ve listed 5 Lessons from Brave, along with some additional commentary, which shouldn’t give away much either:
- A girl can be a hero
- Legends are lessons that ring with truth
- Loving parents are sometimes wrong
- Rebellious teenagers are sometimes really wrong
- Reconciliation comes from setting aside pride, admitting your mistakes, and forgiving completely
As I say at length in that essay, the key difference between Brave and any other fairy tale film I can think of is that the climax is resolved pretty much entirely by the female leads. The male characters, though courageous, engaging, and even heroic in their own ways, are not the heroes of this story at all. Most fairy tale stories involve a male character rescuing the princess or, at best, the female princess jointly resolving the climax with her male counterpart. (The climax of the fairly-well-balanced Tangled comes to mind.)
Aside from some of the characters in The Incredibles, Pixar really hasn’t done much with female characters, but I think that they’ve really surpassed the depth of characterization in any of the more traditional Disney classics. If The Avengers was the blockbuster of the summer, then Brave is the film that’s destined to become a classic.
Pixar Made Me Cry … Again!
One other thing Pixar’s really great at, it turns out, is making me cry. I was a mess five minutes into Finding Nemo, perhaps having some sort of Bambi flashback. As a Facebook meme pointed out, the first 20 minutes of Up contained a more realistic and emotionally impactful (and devastating) romance than all four Twilight books. And I won’t even get into the emotional state I was in when I honestly thought, for about 30 seconds, that they might end the Toy Story saga with all of the toys being melted down in a garbage incinerator!
Despite the fact that Brave‘s climax is incredibly predictable, my wife, my mother-in-law, and I were all in tears. (My 7-year-old son, though he enjoyed the film, did not feel moved to tears. Give it twenty years!) Not outright sobbing, but just a physical manifestation of the well-represented human emotions that we’ve all been through … of misunderstandings with loved ones that spiraled out of control, of tragic mistakes made worse through the heat of emotion, and wanting beyond hope to be able to undo it all.
And, let’s be clear about this, the climax is incredibly predictable. From the second that you know the main story of the film, there’s really very little question how things are going to play out. About 30 minutes into the film, I could have mapped out the entire sequence of events in the climactic scene. I don’t say this to brag, because I don’t think this is particularly insightful on my part. I suspect that pretty much anyone who’s watched a lot of Disney films over the years could see where this one was headed.
Yet, in a way, that sheer predictability made the emotional impact of the scene all that much more impressive. As my wife said, it was “classic.” It resonates with the viewer on a deep level, precisely because we aren’t looking for the cool twist that’s going to blow us away.
No, instead Pixar has just done what they’ve shown they can do again and again: craft a simple, elegant, and emotionally-significant story, deliver it in a superb package, and make us all desperately want more.
- 5 Lessons from Brave – The Philosopher’s Stone
- 10 11 Things Parents Should Know About Brave – GeekDad blog
Andrew Zimmerman Jones is a writer of fiction and non-fiction. He has been a finalist in the Writers of the Future contest and received Honorable Mention in the 2011 Writer’s Digest Science Fiction/Fantasy Competition. In addition to being a contributing editor to Black Gate magazine, Andrew is the About.com Physics Guide and author of String Theory For Dummies. You can follow his exploits on Facebook, Twitter, and even Google+.